In the shimmering heat of a North American summer, Major League Soccer nears its crescendo. As we pass Matchday 24, the league is nearly two-thirds through its marathon season. Clubs are beginning to dream, plan, and fight for a place in the playoffs, all with one shining object in mind: the Philip F. Anschutz Trophy — the MLS Cup.

The trophy, with its gold accents and graceful arcs, embodies the culmination of a season’s toil, ambition, and the belief of millions of fans. It is as much a symbol of local pride as it is a measure of tactical sophistication and resilience. But if the playoffs began today, who would be in, who would face each other, and who stands the best chance of lifting that coveted silverware?

Here’s a thorough look at the bracket, potential matchups, standout players, tactical narratives, and everything in between — your ultimate “gold standard” guide to the 2025 MLS Cup Playoffs, if they began now.

Setting the Stage: The 2025 Regular Season So Far

The 2025 MLS season has been nothing short of spectacular. From unexpected surges by expansion teams to moments of magic by global superstars, every matchday has added a new layer to the league’s evolving story.

As it stands today, the Eastern Conference is led by the consistent and balanced Philadelphia Union. With 43 points from 22 matches and a league-best +16 goal difference, they exemplify an equilibrium between sturdy defense and opportunistic attack.

Hot on their heels is FC Cincinnati with 42 points, a team that has rapidly evolved from underdog to Eastern powerhouse. Nashville SC and Columbus Crew, both on 41 points, provide additional elite competition, while Inter Miami lurks dangerously at fifth place. Miami’s story is inevitably bound to Lionel Messi, whose influence transcends mere goals and assists.

Further down, Orlando City and NYCFC round out the automatic best-of-three spots, while New York Red Bulls and Charlotte FC hover on the cusp, ready to fight it out in the Wild Card clash.

Out West, a changing of the guard is evident. San Diego FC, in just their second season, sit atop with 39 points from 21 matches. Their style is fearless, their recruitment sharp, and their momentum undeniable. The Vancouver Whitecaps and Minnesota United closely follow, each bringing their own tactical identities to the chase.

Rounding out the West’s upper echelon are Portland, Seattle, San Jose, and LAFC — perennial threats capable of upending even the most carefully crafted playoff paths. Below them, Houston Dynamo, Colorado Rapids, and Austin FC battle fiercely for the Wild Card spots.

The Playoff Format: New Twists, Same Ultimate Goal

For 2025, MLS’s expanded playoff structure remains in place. The top seven teams from each conference gain entry into a best-of-three series in Round One. Before that, however, the 8th and 9th seeds clash in a do-or-die Wild Card game to secure the final spot in the bracket.

Round One features best-of-three matchups where higher seeds host Games 1 and 3, emphasizing the importance of regular season seeding. After this initial hurdle, the playoffs shift into single-elimination mode for the Conference Semifinals and Finals. Finally, the two conference champions meet in a single-match MLS Cup Final at a neutral venue.

This format rewards consistency and depth but also leaves plenty of room for underdog magic — a hallmark of North American sports culture.

Eastern Conference: Giants and Jokers

Wild Card Play-In

The New York Red Bulls and Charlotte FC are neck and neck for the last spot, separated by just a point. If they met today, it would be at Red Bull Arena, a fortress where high pressing and transitional play define their DNA. Charlotte, on the other hand, has thrived on moments of individual brilliance, often relying on last-minute heroics.

Prediction: Red Bulls edge it at home, their experience and pressing intensity proving decisive.

First Round (Best-of-Three)

1. Philadelphia Union vs Red Bulls
   Philadelphia have dominated most Eastern matchups this season. Their deep squad rotation, coupled with Andre Blake’s near-impenetrable goalkeeping, makes them favorites against a tired Red Bulls squad.

2. FC Cincinnati vs NYCFC
   Cincinnati’s transformation into a complete team is complete. Led by their dynamic forward line and tactically disciplined midfield, they should overcome NYCFC, though New York’s compact defense could force a third game.

3. Nashville SC vs Orlando City SC
   This battle promises fireworks. Sam Surridge’s clinical finishing makes Nashville favorites, while Orlando’s ability to control midfield tempo gives them an outside chance to cause trouble.

4. Columbus Crew vs Inter Miami
   Perhaps the most tantalizing matchup in the East. Inter Miami, powered by Messi, would enter as the wild card capable of upsetting anyone. Columbus’s organized press and possession game are tailor-made to frustrate individual brilliance — but Messi is no ordinary individual.

Semifinals and Beyond

In projected semifinals, Philadelphia would likely face Miami, while Cincinnati would go against Nashville. Here, Philadelphia’s organization should withstand Miami’s flair, especially over a series that allows tactical readjustments. Cincinnati versus Nashville would be close; expect Cincinnati’s midfield edge to tip the balance.

In the Eastern Conference Final, Philadelphia against Cincinnati offers the clash of the two most complete squads. Philadelphia’s defensive solidity and experience give them the edge, projecting them as Eastern champions.

Western Conference: The Wild Frontier

Wild Card Play-In

Houston Dynamo against Colorado Rapids or Austin FC would set the stage for a rugged elimination battle. Houston’s sharper attack and home form suggest they would prevail against either opponent.

First Round (Best-of-Three)

1. San Diego FC vs Houston Dynamo
   San Diego’s direct attacking style and cohesive defensive line should overwhelm Houston. Expect them to win in two games.

2. Vancouver Whitecaps vs LAFC
   This is a battle of philosophies. Vancouver’s possession-based control versus LAFC’s star-driven spontaneity. Vancouver’s discipline and depth should prevail, though LAFC’s stars can always spring surprises.

3. Minnesota United vs San Jose Earthquakes
   Minnesota’s set-piece mastery and transition play give them the upper hand against San Jose’s fluid, yet defensively fragile approach.

4. Portland Timbers vs Seattle Sounders
   The legendary Cascadia rivalry. Emotion, history, and pride all come into play. While Portland might boast a slightly better record, Seattle’s big-game experience makes them slight favorites.

Semifinals and Beyond

Projected matchups: San Diego vs Seattle, and Vancouver vs Minnesota. San Diego’s momentum and tactical adaptability could see them past Seattle. Meanwhile, Vancouver’s controlled approach should be enough to best Minnesota.

In the Western Conference Final, San Diego vs Vancouver represents a clash between new ambition and refined stability. San Diego’s pace and opportunism could be decisive, marking a fairytale run to the MLS Cup Final in just their second season.

MLS Cup Final: Philadelphia Union vs San Diego FC

If these projections hold, the final offers a captivating narrative: the tried-and-true Eastern powerhouse against the hungry Western upstarts.

Philadelphia would enter as slight favorites, boasting a battle-tested core, airtight defense, and the kind of cohesion built over multiple seasons. San Diego, on the other hand, would bank on their fearless, energetic style to disrupt Philadelphia’s rhythm.

Over 90 minutes on a neutral pitch, anything can happen. But if forced to choose, Philadelphia’s experience and ability to control the tempo suggest they would emerge as champions, perhaps by a single goal margin.

Players to Watch

• Lionel Messi (Inter Miami): Even at 38, Messi remains the league’s biggest draw and can turn any match on its head.

• Sam Surridge (Nashville SC): Leading the Golden Boot race, Surridge is the most lethal striker in the conference.

• Andre Blake (Philadelphia Union): The best goalkeeper in the league, his shot-stopping can single-handedly change playoff narratives.

• Lozano (San Diego FC): The expansion club’s poster boy, capable of blistering runs and decisive finishes.

• Lucas Zelarayán (Columbus Crew): Columbus’s creative metronome, always a threat from set-pieces.

Tactical Themes: Pressing, Possession, and Transition

Several tactical trends define this year’s playoff landscape. High pressing remains a weapon for teams like Red Bulls and Philadelphia, aiming to force mistakes high up the pitch. Meanwhile, possession-based sides like Vancouver attempt to suffocate opponents, minimizing transitions.

Then there are teams such as Minnesota and San Diego that thrive on rapid vertical transitions — one ball over the top or one quick combination and they’re in behind. The tactical diversity promises a variety of match styles and unpredictable dynamics across series.

The X-Factors: Injuries and Fatigue

Miami’s dependence on Messi means his minutes must be managed carefully. Likewise, San Diego’s reliance on Lozano puts them at risk if he were to miss time. Squad depth, always a key factor in MLS given travel and fixture congestion, could play a decisive role. Teams with versatile benches — like Philadelphia and Vancouver — hold a significant advantage.

Financial Power vs Collective Cohesion

A recurring narrative is the battle between star-laden rosters and cohesive, system-driven squads. Miami and LAFC exemplify the former, often winning games through individual brilliance. Philadelphia, Cincinnati, and Vancouver represent the latter, emphasizing drilled patterns and team-first principles.

In knockout football, individual magic can tilt a game, but over multiple matches, structured teams often triumph. This is the “gold standard” of modern soccer logic, and 2025 could reinforce it yet again.

Fan Culture and the Final Push

Supporters’ sections across MLS have been electric this season. San Diego’s “Deep End” ultras, Nashville’s “Backline,” and Philadelphia’s “Sons of Ben” inject a uniquely American flavor into soccer passion.

As the playoffs loom, home-field advantage takes on added significance. The psychological edge, driven by roaring crowds and pre-game choreographies, could become a hidden X-factor, especially in best-of-three series where Game 3s are often decided by nerves as much as tactics.

The Road to the Trophy

The path to lifting the Philip F. Anschutz Trophy is paved with ambition, heartbreak, brilliance, and tactical chess. If the playoffs started today, Philadelphia Union stand as the most complete, most resilient candidate to ascend the podium. But MLS’s unique playoff structure ensures that every match carries the weight of finality and unpredictability.

San Diego’s meteoric rise embodies the romantic possibility of sport, while Messi’s quest in Miami offers a globally compelling storyline. Add in the tactical puzzle of Vancouver and the emotional pull of the Cascadia rivalries, and you have a postseason primed to deliver unforgettable drama.

In the end, whether it is the polished, metallic glint of the trophy reflecting the Philadelphia skyline or the desert sun of San Diego, one truth remains: in MLS, nothing is given; everything is earned.

When that final whistle blows in late September, a new champion will emerge, immortalized in the echoes of stadium chants and the glittering confetti of victory.

No comments yet.