New York City, with its gravity-defying skyscrapers and dreamlike whirl of culture, holds an unparalleled reputation for luxury. Yet as Annie Harrigan insightfully explores in her Thrillist piece “How to Spend Two Fancy but Affordable Days in NYC,” the idea that one must empty their wallet to taste the high life in Manhattan is, delightfully, a myth.

With careful planning, insider knowledge, and a slight spirit of adventure, two days of grandiose, Instagram-worthy experiences are not only achievable—they’re refreshingly accessible. Building on Harrigan’s keen observations, this guide will expand the itinerary, adding reflections, hidden gems, and a few bonus experiences to construct a 48-hour blueprint that proves living lavishly doesn’t always require living large.

Day One: An Affordable Introduction to Old-World Glamour and Modern Indulgence

Morning: Victorian Mansions and French Breakfasts

Harrigan’s call to explore free art galleries hidden within historic mansions is pure gold. One cannot claim a slightly fancy NYC weekend without stepping inside the Ukrainian Institute of America, housed in the Charles Schwab mansion on Fifth Avenue. This Gilded Age relic offers rotating contemporary art exhibitions—all free to the public. Arrive early to savor the rare solitude such grandeur provides.

For breakfast:

Skip the $40 hotel buffet. Head instead to Balthazar Bakery in SoHo. Pick up a pain au chocolat and a latte for under $10, all while basking in the Parisian ambience that feels far more decadent than the price suggests.

Midday: Tailored Perfume and Private Gardens

One of the more inspired secrets Harrigan shares is the possibility of expert fragrance customizations without breaking the bank. Le Labo (Nolita or Williamsburg) offers complimentary personalization with any purchase—a small indulgence that feels entirely bespoke.

Bonus Tip:

After your fragrance journey, stroll through the Elizabeth Street Garden, a lush pocket of sculptures and wildflowers amid SoHo’s chaos. Entry is free, the atmosphere priceless.

Afternoon: Lunch with a View

Lunch should be a moment of affordable splendor.

Skip the Michelin-starred dining rooms (for now) and opt for Eataly’s rooftop restaurant, Serra by Birreria, at the Flatiron location. Their lunch specials often hover around $20, and with seasonal décor changing throughout the year, it offers a garden-in-the-sky vibe usually reserved for high-end rooftop clubs.

Evening: Broadway for (Almost) Pennies

Harrigan’s advice to enter Broadway ticket lotteries is crucial. Apps like TodayTix make it shockingly easy to win access to world-class productions for as little as $30. Alternatively, brave the TKTS booth at Times Square for same-day discount tickets.

Dinner tip before the show:

Book a reservation at Joe Allen, a legendary Theater District institution where stars dine quietly, prices remain fair, and the vibe is old New York unpolished glamour.

Day Two: Chic Adventures Beyond Manhattan

Morning: Bagels and a Brooklyn Museum Tour

No NYC itinerary is complete without bagels. Seek out Bagel Pub in Brooklyn for a toasted sesame with scallion cream cheese and smoked salmon—luxurious and satisfying for under $15.

After breakfast, take Harrigan’s tip to embrace the subway system. A quick ride on the 2/3 train delivers you to the Brooklyn Museum. Admission is suggested (read: pay-what-you-wish), allowing you to tailor your extravagance level. Marvel at the museum’s expansive feminist art wing, or lose yourself among ancient Egyptian artifacts—all without the Met’s heavy crowds.

Bonus:

Don’t miss Prospect Park right next door—an Olmsted-designed masterpiece where carriage rides, lakes, and nature paths feel worlds away from the city bustle.

Midday: Spa Breaks Without the Sticker Shock

Want to live like a Rockefeller without the bill?

Head to CityWell Brooklyn, a boutique bathhouse offering luxurious hot tubs, saunas, and massages at prices that undercut the glitzy hotel spas. A day pass runs around $55, offering hours of restorative bliss.

Lunch tip:

Nearby Claro offers an Oaxacan-inspired prix-fixe brunch with handmade tortillas and mole-driven dishes under $40—proof that Michelin-starred indulgence doesn’t always demand Michelin-starred prices.

Afternoon: Designer Windows and Hidden Greenhouses

Return to Manhattan by subway and make your way to Fifth Avenue. You don’t have to shop at Bergdorf Goodman to enjoy it; window shopping amid the grand displays is an art form itself. Allow yourself a coffee break at The Plaza Food Hall, where $5 espresso feels like a passport into the upper crust world of Eloise.

Hidden treasure:

Sneak into the Ford Foundation Building Atrium near the United Nations. Few tourists know this lush, tropical indoor garden exists—free to enter, breathtaking to behold.

Evening: Nightcaps and Skyline Dreams

End your two-day fantasy at a rooftop bar—without the $25 cocktail tab shock.

Head to Harriet’s Rooftop at 1 Hotel Brooklyn Bridge during happy hour. Their spectacular skyline views across the East River and eco-chic ambiance redefine what affordable luxury can look like.

Final Dinner Tip:

Reserve a late table at King in SoHo, where the menu is minimalist but the flavors are maximal. Dinner here can cost as little as $40 per person if you choose carefully—a fitting, quietly sophisticated finale.

Additional Pro Tips Inspired by Harrigan’s Wisdom

1. Timing Is Everything

A luxurious weekend is as much about avoiding lines as it is about saving dollars.

• Visit museums in the morning.
• Enter lotteries the night before.
• Book restaurants for slightly off-peak hours (think 5:30 PM or 9:00 PM) for easier availability and better seating.

2. Wear the Right Shoes

Fancy on a budget means embracing movement.

Subway stairs, cobbled SoHo streets, Central Park rambles—all are made infinitely better with stylish but walkable footwear. Your comfort ensures you can maximize spontaneous discovery without collapsing into an Uber.

3. Mind the Dress Code

A little sartorial effort unlocks subtle luxuries.

Upscale bars, rooftop lounges, and even some art galleries favor those who lean into understated elegance. Think casual-chic: a good blazer, tasteful sneakers, statement accessories.

4. Don’t Fear Asking for Tips

One of Harrigan’s most New Yorker tips is simply asking locals. In a city famed for being brusque, most natives are more than happy to point you toward a hidden speakeasy, a free event, or an overlooked gem—especially if you’re genuinely curious.

Thoughts

In her article, Annie Harrigan beautifully dispels the notion that enjoying the finer things in New York requires platinum cards or trust funds.

New York rewards the curious, the prepared, and the imaginative.

It is entirely possible to experience two days of elegance, excitement, and indulgence without descending into financial ruin.

No comments yet.