When the camera sneaks over the rubble — block after block of soot and stone — it isn’t just capturing a demolished city. It’s showing a civilization leveled to its bones, where dirty-faced urchins, half-Newsie, half-feral, stake their small claims among broken rebar and cracked concrete. Their kingdoms are built from smashed bricks and bad dreams, destined to collapse at a gust of wind or a glint of greed. These kids know the future’s a broom sweeping them into history’s forgotten gutters. They know the floods are coming. Sing while you can, they say, because the river is hungry and time doesn’t wait for anyone.

It’s a brutal opening for what many still call a “musical,” but in Steven Spielberg’s West Side Story — a 2021 film still shaping conversations into 2025 — that term feels too simple, too clean. What Spielberg made, and what the world finally caught up to appreciating in the years since, was a musical built from real blood, sweat, and cracked pavement.

This isn’t the sanitized spectacle of mid-century Hollywood musicals. No snap-fingered clichés. No makeup darkening white faces to pretend. This version of West Side Story scrapes up every inch of its potential, rubbing it raw against the modern day without losing the fundamental heart that made the story timeless.

And in doing so, Spielberg didn’t just remake a classic — he redeemed it.

Learning to Trust the Remake

I used to hate remakes. To me, they symbolized laziness, the fear of new ideas, the recycling of culture into thinner and thinner versions. But Suspiria (2018) changed that. Luca Guadagnino’s radical reinterpretation took my favorite horror movie and didn’t just honor it — it rebuilt it into something I loved even more. Since then, I’ve stopped fretting. If remakes are bad, the originals remain untouched. If they’re good? They can transform your understanding of the story itself.

Spielberg’s West Side Story landed firmly in that latter camp.

I’ll admit it here, up front: I never loved Robert Wise’s 1961 original. I respected it. I appreciated it. But love? No. It always felt to me like the polished end of a genre I couldn’t fully connect with — all swirling skirts and bouncing songs over a hard, aching core that never fully broke through the Hollywood shine. Worse, the original’s brownface and broad stereotypes created a gap I couldn’t ignore.

So, I came into Spielberg’s version wary. Expecting more reverence for material I already found uneven. Expecting a dance I wouldn’t want to join.

But from the opening shot, I knew this was different.

Spielberg’s Crucial Changes

Spielberg and screenwriter Tony Kushner didn’t simply replicate West Side Story scene-for-scene. They rebuilt it, bone by careful bone. They understood that time and progress demanded changes — changes not just cosmetic, but fundamental.

First, the casting. No longer could white actors in darkened makeup pass for Puerto Rican characters. This version gave those roles to actors who lived closer to those experiences — Rachel Zegler, Ariana DeBose, David Alvarez — each infusing the story with life and legitimacy that the original always lacked. Watching DeBose’s Anita electrify the screen with righteous anger and heartbreak wasn’t just thrilling; it was healing.

Second, the storytelling itself. Spielberg and Kushner didn’t shy away from the systemic forces pressing down on the Jets and Sharks. Gentrification, racism, poverty — these forces are no longer background noise. They are the invisible, brutal engine of the tragedy. You feel it in every frame: the skyscrapers rising like sterile tombstones, the cops caring more about clearing neighborhoods than protecting kids, the city swallowing everything whole.

Third, the music and choreography. Spielberg understood that the joy, the life-force of West Side Story, was always in the movement. The dances erupt naturally from the world, each step defiant against the darkness creeping in. Kaminski’s cinematography doesn’t just capture these sequences — it dances with them, gliding, swooping, twirling, but never losing the grit underneath.

Emotional Realism: The Pain Behind the Beauty

What surprised me most watching Spielberg’s version — and what resonates even stronger in 2025 — is how much real pain it allows to exist on screen.

This isn’t just about young lovers doomed by tribalism. It’s about kids trapped in a system built to fail them, swinging fists because that’s all the world taught them they could do. The Jets aren’t sanitized here — they’re angry, broken boys made cruel by their own helplessness. The Sharks aren’t simply a rival gang — they’re a displaced community, fighting to hold onto dignity in a city that sees them as disposable.

Maria and Tony’s love story is still sweet, still beautiful — but it’s laced with the gut-punch knowledge that love alone can’t overcome a system built on division and distrust.

This tension isn’t just intellectually satisfying; it’s emotionally devastating. When the tragedy finally unfolds, it feels earned — a culmination of forces bigger than any single mistake.

Spielberg didn’t make a musical that floats above reality. He made one that bleeds.

Why It Matters More Now

Watching West Side Story in 2025, you realize how eerily prescient Spielberg’s 2021 vision was. In a world still grappling with gentrification, police violence, immigration battles, and resurgent tribalism, this story feels freshly urgent. The specifics might have changed, but the pattern remains the same: divide, demonize, destroy.

The skyscrapers still rise. The poor are still boxed out. The tribes still form along racial, national, or class lines. The blood still spills needlessly.

And yet… so do the songs. So do the dances. So does the joy, defiant and shining through the cracks.

That’s the brilliance of Spielberg’s adaptation: it doesn’t surrender to despair. It holds space for beauty amidst the wreckage. It acknowledges the system is broken but insists that love, community, and human dignity matter anyway.

Legacy: A Remake That Redefines

In 2025, West Side Story stands as one of the rare remakes that doesn’t just update a classic — it justifies its existence. It deepens, expands, and corrects. It invites old fans to see something new and new audiences to understand why the story mattered in the first place.

Rachel Zegler’s Maria isn’t just a love-struck girl; she’s a woman clawing her way toward agency in a hostile world. Ansel Elgort’s Tony is a boy aching for redemption in a society that offers no second chances. And Ariana DeBose’s Anita… she doesn’t just steal scenes; she steals breath.

Watching Rita Moreno — a living bridge between the original and the remake — bring quiet, aching dignity to her role as Valentina is almost overwhelming. Her presence connects the old dream to the new reality, showing that change is possible, even if it comes slowly and painfully.

Final Word: A New Kind of Musical

Spielberg’s West Side Story isn’t just a musical. It’s a testament.

A testament to the power of art to evolve. A testament to the importance of representation not as an afterthought, but as a foundation. A testament to the simple, brutal, beautiful truth that love, even when crushed by the world, leaves a mark — a song, a dance, a memory.

Watching it now, in a world that feels no less chaotic than the rubble-strewn streets that open the film, West Side Story feels more vital than ever.

It’s a film that dares to hope, even as it grieves. That dares to sing, even as the floods come.

And in 2025, that’s still worth singing about.

 

No comments yet.